Book review: The Punishment She Deserves, by Elizabeth George

The Punishment She Deserves
Elizabeth George
Viking

Elizabeth George is a perennial favourite of mine – I’ve been reading her mysteries for 30 years now, and I don’t think there has been one I haven’t enjoyed.
The upright, proper Detective Inspector Thomas Lynley and his brilliant-but-unconventional sidekick Detective Sergeant Barbara Havers are always a pleasure to follow around the British countryside, solving whatever murder they happen to be working on.
This time, the mystery is the apparent suicide of a church deacon who had been arrested after claims of child molestation. On first glance, it appears obvious that he killed himself while in police custody, but a closer look shows many unusual happenings in the small medieval British town of Ludlow.
Regular readers will love The Punishment She Deserves, for its focus on Lynley and Havers, who solve a traditional crime with lots of sordid details and side notes. Newcomers won’t be lost in the back story and can jump right in. George lives in Washington State, but usually sets her mysteries in England.
For the first 200 or so pages – the length of a regular novel – Havers is inspecting the suicide with Isabelle Ardery, the Acting Superintendent who is dealing with a bit of an alcohol problem. Ardery’s story is interesting, but I was beginning to wonder if the author had tired of Lynley and his story. But thankfully, Lynley is at the heart of part two of the book, which clocks in at another 500 pages. Yep, this is a long book. But it’s worth it.
There’s a bit of a treatise on motherhood hidden within the pages of this murder mystery. I won’t go into too many details, except to say that readers will meet a neglectful mother, a mother who is unable to let go and a mother who is unable to stop hovering. Throw in a bit of foreign culture, a bit of religion and a bit of the freedom and damage of the first couple of years of college and you’ve got the makings of a superb murder mystery.
The only complaint I have about Elizabeth George’s mysteries is that the back story – the story of Lynley, Havers, Simon, Deborah, and all of the other characters – moves so slowly. By my count, Deborah and Simon have been trying for a baby for several decades, but they’ve barely aged.
Moving their story slowly means readers keep coming back for a little tidbit about how these characters they love are doing, but it also means readers can be disappointed with little progress.
After 30 years of Lynley, faithful readers should know not to expect a whole bunch of personal details. The Punishment She Deserves is nonetheless a delightful read, and one that brings the series back to its traditional roots. We will just have to wait for the next one to find out the gossip.
tracy.sherlock@gmail.com